The Syrian government has rejected Kurdish autonomy to be included in a new draft constitution for the country being written by Russia.

Article 40 in the draft constitution called for decentralized “people’s societies”.

“The Kurdish cultural self-ruling systems and its organizations use both the Arabic and Kurdish languages equally,” the draft reads.

The Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD), however are refusing to budge that federalism can be the only solution.

The Syrian government has rejected local autonomy or recognition of the Kurdish language on an equal level to Arabic.

The difficulty would also mean that other minority languages would also need to be recognized including Greek, Aramaic, Turkish and many others that the PYD have not advocated for.

According to the Syrian state media, during the Syrian peace talks in Astana last week, the Syrian government envoy Bashar Jaafari, said that the issue of federalism would be decided “by all Syrians and not decided unilaterally by a single component,” adding that all ideas “even one as crazy as federalism, must be put to a democratic vote”

“It’s completely unacceptable for a group of people to decide to create a statelet and call it federalism,” Jaafari continued.

Share this article:
  • 907
  •  
  • 18
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
    925
    Shares
ALSO READ  Large protest held in Qamishli against Turkish and US forces in Syria: video

Notice: All comments represent the view of the commenter and not necessarily the views of AMN.

All comments that are not spam or wholly inappropriate are approved, we do not sort out opinions or points of view that are different from ours.

This is a Civilized Place for Public Discussion

Please treat this discussion with the same respect you would a public park. We, too, are a shared community resource — a place to share skills, knowledge and interests through ongoing conversation.

These are not hard and fast rules, merely guidelines to aid the human judgment of our community and keep this a clean and well-lighted place for civilized public discourse.

Improve the Discussion

Help us make this a great place for discussion by always working to improve the discussion in some way, however small. If you are not sure your post adds to the conversation, think over what you want to say and try again later.

The topics discussed here matter to us, and we want you to act as if they matter to you, too. Be respectful of the topics and the people discussing them, even if you disagree with some of what is being said.

Be Agreeable, Even When You Disagree

You may wish to respond to something by disagreeing with it. That’s fine. But remember to criticize ideas, not people. Please avoid:

  • Name-calling
  • Ad hominem attacks
  • Responding to a post’s tone instead of its actual content
  • Knee-jerk contradiction

Instead, provide reasoned counter-arguments that improve the conversation.

27 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 12:45

The suggestion comes from Russia that is a democratic country with the cultural pluralism that is proposed in the draft constitution. So the Russians know what they are talking about. Rejecting is plain dumb or at least Arab parochialism. The Syrian government wants to build consent after a foreign sponsored civil war. Minority rights are one way to it. And a way to get another non authoritarian profile that especially the armed opposition lacks.

jvillain
Regular
Commenter
Upvoted
jvillain
2017-02-01 15:52
Reply to  Stern Daler

The Kurds want to take the oil fields for themselves. Use the money from it to build up their military and then permanently split throwing out any one living there that isn’t a Kurd. Look to Iraq to see what is coming.

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 20:09
Reply to  jvillain

Better they than Erdogan. They are at least natives and Syrians.

Furat
Furat
2017-02-01 16:42
Reply to  Stern Daler

Russia is setting the stage for Syria to be divided as the Americans did in Iraq. There can be decentralization and some ‘language’ autonomy as long as it does not divide the country along ethnic and religious lines.
I hope this is not coordinated with US and Israel for the long-term plan to create ethnic and religious states in the region to justify the ‘Jewishness’ of Israel. I hope Russia revisited its plans and ensure that Syria keeps united as a society (most improtant) and country

Daeshbags Sux
Master
Upvoted
Rookie Mentor
Commenter
Daeshbags Sux
2017-02-01 19:48
Reply to  Furat

Nope, Russia is simply a federal state too with MANY minorities so they know how it works! “to justify the ‘Jewishness’ of Israel” => Israelis don’t give a f**k of what Arabs are doing as long as they’re not under attack! Moreover, even Coran says the country belongs to the Jews, now, Israel ain’t a religious state : it’s absolutely secular. The Jews are a people. Many of them are atheists, you even have Christian Jews who are badly seen by the Haredi minority, you know, the religious extremists who are anti-zionists and a pain in the a*s of Israel… Read more »

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 20:14
Reply to  Daeshbags Sux

=> Israel ain’t a religious state : it’s absolutely secular. => Nope was. The ultra orthodox have been given to much sway.

falcemartello
falcemartello
2017-02-03 01:30
Reply to  Stern Daler

Israel is not a secular state. Non jews are not allowed to purchase land on Israel proper. and the occupied territories are all under military governance since 1967.They had just voted circa 14 months ago to change its status to a JEWISH STATE hence nufin secular bout it. It also states that non jews cannot be head of STATE IE: President.
Post Sriptum :Israel is a racist apartheid state.
The Kurds have been infiltrated by Zionist going way back to the 70’s. Iraqi Kurds in particular. It’s a zionist ploy to divide and conquer.

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-03 14:56
Reply to  falcemartello

I wrote it was, didn’t I? BTW. AFAIK You cannot become Syrian President if You are Christian or Jew. Most Jews property and all possessions were taken in Muslim Arab countries after 1948. And the Kurds are treated as scum by Arabs anyway since before the 70ies or 1948. Now the out-dogs have joined. The Arabs made that, didn’t they? p.s. So I do not understand what are You complaining about?

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 20:12
Reply to  Furat

Furat For that best for Syria to embrace them now. Alsatians are French nationals German speaking – they consider themselves French – because they have the same rights.

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 20:37
Reply to  Furat

@Furat The draft has safeguards against splitting up Iraq style. Russia has experience – Russia is a multi ethnic country. The US English have suppressed all other ethnic groups that made their country great. They do only know a single language country & have split Iraq in two.

ozybrum
Regular
Commenter
Upvoted
ozybrum
2017-02-02 06:42
Reply to  Stern Daler

…..and how many languages enjoy equal status to Russian in the Russian Federation?

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-03 15:46
Reply to  ozybrum

@ozybrum AFAIK none. Russian is used for administration and higher education. But locally and regionally language and culture of national minorities is supported and facilitated not suppressed. AFAIK article 68.3 of the Russian constitution allows schooling in the local language besides Russian. That is why the draft constitution is worded like it is. p.s. Russia has about 100 minority languages.

Diego Prendergast
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Diego Prendergast
2017-02-01 12:56

Yes the Syrian Kurds can continue as they always have as free citizens of Syria. Syria for Syrians.

Faith
Faith
2017-02-01 11:55

My name is Zeus and from time immemorial we’ve resided in the great Syria and lived and loved and fought many epic battles.. However we speak Greek & we want our own state. My neighbor wanted to say something as well. Yes, I am his neighbor and my name is Ercatan. I am from Turkey but I reside in Syria and assert my right not to incriminate myself so will not be discussing battles and what sides we helped.. But, to get to the point, we speak Turkish and want our own state within the great Sourya! ??? *Jaafari, Syria,… Read more »

albert Samtu
albert Samtu
2017-02-01 15:15

This article’s heading is complete bunk,and the article itself is ill conceived. The Syrian government is fully aware of the draft document which was jointly developed with the Russians. The so called autonomous communities the writer mentioned, have been approved as points of discussion in Geneva.

#3AM
Newbie
Upvoted
#3AM
2017-02-02 06:11

Russians have been patronizing Syria, haven’t they? They would love to get of hook I mean sanctions. It seems like Mr Putin would like to have another “Yalta”.

Harun ar Rasheed
Harun ar Rasheed
2017-02-02 13:46

Assad said in a speech last week that _Iran_ is Syria’s closest partner and has stood with Syria like a friend since the foreign mercenaries began the “revolution” in 2011. With Russia in the spotlight I think it is significant that he made a point to mention Iran. Russia is acting like it owns Syria and as a large power it has a certain arrogance of the powerful. Russia is primarily in this for Russia let’s not forget. It just happens that Russia and Syria both share an interest in keeping America/Israel/GCC from dominating the region. Splitting up Syria is… Read more »

Nestor Arapa
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Nestor Arapa
2017-02-01 15:54

En cuanto a lenguas y costumbres, cito un ejemplo de un país en América del Sur, antes solo se llamaba “Bolivia” ahora se llama “Pluri Nacional de Bolivia”… El gobierno Sirio a cedido a los caprichos de Erdogan.

Daeshbags Sux
Master
Upvoted
Rookie Mentor
Commenter
Daeshbags Sux
2017-02-01 20:39

“The Syrian government has rejected Kurdish autonomy to be included in a new draft constitution for the country being written by Russia.” => Little problem! Syrian govt mostly let them down during the 2014 Daesh Bitzkrieg. They’re ALREADY autonomous! If the Syrian govt thinks that PYD will accept Baath rule again, they’re simply dreaming! Remember that the concept of Baath party is an Arab mix of Nationalism and Socialism… Nazional-Zozialist in German… Guess who funded the Arab nationalism until 1945, you’ll soon understand why they were (and still are) anti-Israelis, LOL : the most prominent Arab leader after WW2 was… Read more »

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-03 15:29
Reply to  Daeshbags Sux

You are right – it will be hard to reunite YPD areas with Syria forcefully. They did not side with the terrorists. There can be no justification. Except that You want to join Erdogan in their genocide. Only Kurdish withholding non Kurdish settled oil and gas areas from federal control can cause problems and justify action. Note the Federal government here Syrian central government not federal areas here West Kurdistan own such assets. Russia will likely support a form of federation. BTW. I told You before in this forum/comment section: Amin al-Husseini was great Mufti of Jerusalem not German SS… Read more »

Pete
Pete
2017-02-01 10:06

“It’s completely unacceptable for a group of people to decide to create a statelet and call it federalism” – they can do what they want. They live there, they’ve been abused by the Syrian dictatorship since it began, and they beat ISIS to claim their freedom. Assad can f*** himself, his day is run.

AmericaIsEvil
AmericaIsEvil
2017-02-01 11:40
Reply to  Pete

They beat ISIS? The SAA beat ISIS. And for your information, the majority of the SDF consists of Arabs, which is what the USA fails to see. These people will never stand behind a sovereign Kurdish state. Stop watching CNN and do some actual research.

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 20:24
Reply to  AmericaIsEvil

@AmericaIsEvil The SAA was occupied by the Fiends of Syria backed not so moderate murderers – While the Kurds and Arab allies had free hands to take most IS held territories and beat IS.
p.s. It is just recent that the SAA has gained strength, time and will to fight IS.

Faith
Faith
2017-02-01 11:51
Reply to  Pete

My name is Zeus and from time immemorial we’ve resided in the great Syria and lived and loved and fought many epic battles.. However we speak Greek & we want our own state. My neighbor wanted to say something as well. Yes, I am his neighbor and my name is Ercatan. I am from Turkey but I reside in Syria and assert my right not to incriminate myself so will not be discussing battles and what sides we helped.. But, to get to the point, we speak Turkish and want our own state within the great Sourya! ??? *Jaafari, Syria,… Read more »

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 20:30
Reply to  Faith

@Faith My name is Stern Daler and Yours is a double post. Greeks have their own state – so have Turkmens. We speak about cultural federalism. Because that is what the Russians who come from a multi ethnic country and know how it is done and what it means wrote that into the draft constitution. They also put the safeguard against splitting up in.

FuckIslam
FuckIslam
2017-02-01 12:28
Reply to  Pete

no pete, you can go f**k yourself! Syria is a single country, it should not be divided! I like the kurds, but if they insist on this issue, there will be another war…

Stern Daler
Famed Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Stern Daler
2017-02-01 12:39
Reply to  Pete

=> “It’s completely unacceptable for a group of people to decide to create a statelet and call it federalism” => The person speaking does not know his countries history. Just because France and Britain have failed – because of their colonial interests – to create federal statelets this does not mean it must stay so. Cultural pluralism in education and using a second language at a local or provincial level is not the end of Arabic at the national level. It’s completely unacceptable for the majority to decide about minority rights. Doing so is the political level of IS and… Read more »