The approximate chronology of the events that ultimately led to seizure of Palmyra (Tadmor) by the so-called “Islamic State of Iraq and Syria” (ISIS) was described by an officer in Syrian Arab Army’s Tiger Forces, a member of the group that was stationed in Palmyra, being the last unit to leave the city after its fall.

Officer’s notes can be read below:

Tadmor. Saturday, December 10, 2016. 8:00 AM.

Repeatedly incoming Russian satellite images alerting about the upcoming ISIS assault. We receive an alert about ISIS terrorists gathering around city’s perimeter. Air forces are busy striking ISIS at the oil fields to the north, not having enough time to react.

Al-Sawamea military object and surroundings (Grain Silos). Saturday, December 10, 2016. 10:00 AM.

The point is located 15 kilometers east of Tadmor on the Al-Sukhnah – Tadmor road.
City garrison:
– «Military shield forces» (military police volunteers), «Al-Badiyah forces» (internal security) consisting of several units – «Al-Saeemah», «Zenoubia», «Heart of Syria» and «Al-Sheikh Suleiman». About 1,800 fighters overall;
– Units from 11th and 18th tank divisions equipped with six 130mm and six 122mm artillery guns, 7 «Grad» MLRS (multiple launch rocket systems) and 12 tanks;
– «Liwa Al-Fatemeyoun» (Afghani Fatemeyoun Brigade) forces, with 1,200 fighters and lots of solid-looking military equipment;
– A unit of Tiger Forces, about 150 fighters, defending the weakest point southeast of the city.

So, 7 kilometers east of Grain Silos area, 2 ISIS cars and a tank moving through Al-Sukhnah road were spotted from the Jabal Tar hilltop where an observation post was located.
Air force commenced airstrikes destroying both automobiles. The tank kept moving. As it turned out, it was loaded with explosives – imagine a VBIED (vehicle borne improvised explosive device) of a 10-ton weight able to damage anything in a radius of 400 meters.
Due to unknown reasons, 18th Division’s «Konkurs» anti-tank guided weapon (ATGW) crew was not able to destroy the tank. When it was in about 200 meters from defensive positions, the armoured vehicle was hit with an anti-tank grenade launcher.

This would cause massive explosion. Soldiers panicked and started to retreat from their positions. After that, everything calmed down, as terrorists were preparing to assault Jabal Tar mountain.
Without any serious reason, troops started abandoning their positions all over the frontline. Withdrawal of «Al-Fatemeyoun Brigade» provoked panic among the other city defenders, especially when the latter saw how quickly the Afghan fighters were retreating with all their heavy weapons and equipment. Note that they retreated westward leaving the city instead of staying inside.
They were followed by the «Military shield forces» and 18th division units. On the other hand, 11th division soldiers withdrew to Tadmor itself and established defensive positions along city’s perimeter. Meanwhile, on the southeastern flank, only Colonel Sukheil’s forces, airport defenders and Air Force Intelligence troops remained (total number of about 100 soldiers).
Colonel Sukheil’s forces dispersed establishing temporary defensive positions on eastern and southeastern flanks.

Jabal Tar area. Saturday, December 10, 2016. 11:00 AM.

Jabal Tar mountaintop overlooks the city of Tadmor. Those who control it effectively control Tadmor and the road leading to the city. Usually, ISIS begin their assaults with suicide bomber attacks followed by direct close range firefights with the opposing party, in order to evade airstrikes. Tar mountain is a crucial link in city’s defensive perimeter. To possess it means to possess initiative. The initial garrison defending the mountain consisted of 500 fighters from Tiger Forces. However, by this day, it was almost halved because a lot of soldiers left due to a 5-month delay of salary payment.

Also, there were 2 defensive positions of 18th division units at Jabal Antar mountain.

The attack on Jabal Tar began with terrorists firing heavy machineguns mounted on 4 pickup trucks. Those trucks covered movements of 2 battle tanks. In addition to that, ISIS shelled Army’s positions with 130mm artillery guns and 120mm and 82mm mortars, as well as “hell cannons”. Note that Jabal Tar did not have any anti tank weapons except for 2 tanks which were quickly destroyed with direct hits. Also, the defenders lost their 23mm and 14mm heavy machineguns.

Therefore, only infantry soldiers left on the mountaintop clashing with the enemy face-to-face.
Soldiers were able to destroy both ISIS tanks along with accompanying militants, in spite of their own losses. By 5:00 PM, the attack was finally repulsed. The Army lost some points, 18th division units withdrew towards T-4 Military Airport. Tiger Forces withstood the attack, despite sustaining losses (there was a lot of wounded, several martyrs and a few prisoners captured by ISIS). For everyone who keeps asking where the air forces were, I’ll say: air forces are unable to support ground troops in such conditions [close-range combat], and thus their support was limited to striking terrorists’ supply routes.

Tadmor. Saturday, December 10, 2016. 5:00 PM.

Russians blew up an ammo depot on their military base in Tadmor before abandoning it. Sky above the city turned into a firework festival causing panic among the civilians and military personnel stationed in the city. As a result, the city was completely evacuated.

Tadmor. Saturday, December 10, 2016. 6:00 PM.

The city is empty. No civilians, no military, except for a couple of units of Mukhabarat (State security) and police.
Head of «Al-Badiyah» security forces, along with several officers, would move back and forth in his luxury armoured “Cadillac” to prove the High Command that he did not abandon the city. At the same time, those 2,500 fighters of «Al-Badiyah» and «Military shield» were no longer in Tadmor, none of them were defending the city.
Only soldiers of the 11th division remained, along with their tanks.
We contacted our commander, reported the situation and requested immediate backup. Colonel Sukheil ordered to hold the positions and told us that reinforcements are coming.
Of all the other forces who were supposed to defend Tadmor – namely, 18th division, «Al-Badiyah forces», «Fatemeyoun brigade» – no one stayed, except for Major General Shawkat with his “Cadillac” and 10 officers, along with a pickup truck mounted with a heavy machinegun.

Tadmor. Saturday, December 10, 2016. 10:00 PM.

No reinforcements arrived.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 0:00 AM.

Some 100 fighters of «Fatemeyoun brigade» and 70 soldiers of the 18th division returned to the city. 11th division never left, and we salute them for their courage and resilience.
With these forces combined, we managed to reinforce the eastern flank of defense, more or less. Some 40 soldiers positioned themselves along the Al-Sukhnah road.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 1:00 AM.

An ISIS car bomb managed to sneak to 11th division’s positions at Al-Sukhnah road. Tanks were damaged, several soldiers killed and wounded. The rest stayed at their positions, despite what just happened. We sent 60 soldiers to reinforce Al-Amariyah district and a hill of the same name which had been defenseless since morning. However, we left the 410 Warehouse area due to lack of manpower.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 3:00 AM.

Commander contacted us to clarify the situation. We are thankful to Colonel for being in touch and not believing to the officials who lied about the real situation on the ground.
But the 410 Warehouse area was empty, and we were unable to secure that key point. Once again, lack of manpower.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 9:00 AM.

ISIS began their attack striking simultaneously at Jabal Tar and in Al-Amariyah neighbourhood. During the night, a group of ISIS terrorists disguised as military infiltrated the neighbourhood, seized the Al-Amariyah hill and suddenly struck us from the rear. Another group of militants supported them from the 410 Warehouse area. Control over Al-Amariyah hill grants control over whole city. Sitting on top of it you can just shoot everything that moves in the streets.

Jabal Tar.

Meanwhile, 4 tanks and 3 pickup trucks mounted with heavy machineguns attacked the Army’s positions at Tar mountain. Their defense was weakened due to cold weather and hunger. No reinforcements came, only false promises. Jabal Tar fell after all the garrison was martyred, wounded or captured as POW.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 11.00 AM.

ISIS controls Al-Amariyah hill, with militants targeting anything that moves inside the city. Jabal Tar is under ISIS control.
The rest of our troops were forced to retreat to southern part of Tadmor and position at Tadmor’s Triangle roundabout and in Tadmor Orchards.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 1:00 PM.

All the military personnel withdrew to Hayyan Junction, except for about 200 soldiers of Tiger Forces with 2 tanks and machineguns, to cover the withdrawal of the rest. Also, we still had those luxury cars of “Al-Badiyah” officers who proved to High Command that they had stayed in the city – but unfortunately, without their troops. We positioned ourselves in between the orchards and Triangle roundabout.

Tadmor. Sunday, December 11, 2016. 2:00 PM.

We are surrounded by ISIS. Terrorists are in full control of the city and the highway. Nowhere to retreat. Thank God we still have the General and his officers with luxury cars, who finally contacted the High Command and called in 6 Mi-28 attack helicopters to cover our retreat through the orchards. They covered us from both left and right flanks. We managed to escape the encirclement.

During all these events two journalists, brother Eyad Al-Hussein and brother Omar Dirmama, stayed in touch with me taking notes and making a chronology of the events.

That’s how Tadmor and the surroundings fell.

SAA’s Tiger Forces officer. December 12, 2016.

Advertisements
Share this article:
  • 296
  •  
  • 2
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
    298
    Shares
ALSO READ  Syria Army foils jihadist attack in northern Hama
Writer, translator. Former communications engineer. Contributor at both AMN Russian and AMN English.

Notice: All comments represent the view of the commenter and not necessarily the views of AMN.

All comments that are not spam or wholly inappropriate are approved, we do not sort out opinions or points of view that are different from ours.

This is a Civilized Place for Public Discussion

Please treat this discussion with the same respect you would a public park. We, too, are a shared community resource — a place to share skills, knowledge and interests through ongoing conversation.

These are not hard and fast rules, merely guidelines to aid the human judgment of our community and keep this a clean and well-lighted place for civilized public discourse.

Improve the Discussion

Help us make this a great place for discussion by always working to improve the discussion in some way, however small. If you are not sure your post adds to the conversation, think over what you want to say and try again later.

The topics discussed here matter to us, and we want you to act as if they matter to you, too. Be respectful of the topics and the people discussing them, even if you disagree with some of what is being said.

Be Agreeable, Even When You Disagree

You may wish to respond to something by disagreeing with it. That’s fine. But remember to criticize ideas, not people. Please avoid:

  • Name-calling
  • Ad hominem attacks
  • Responding to a post’s tone instead of its actual content
  • Knee-jerk contradiction

Instead, provide reasoned counter-arguments that improve the conversation.

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Member
Newbie
Commenter
nikbi

All those rag tag militia forces should be dismantled. Good soldiers are getting killed because of them. NDF in E Homs is a special case. They are bunch of corrupt smugglers. Court-martial all their leaders.

Floriangeyer
Member
Active Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Floriangeyer

Failure to have sufficient anti tank weapons, food, water, stores and ammo on the critical heights is unforgivable . It also seems that entrenching tools are not used these days and unless there is a mechanical digger no artillery emplacements are dug and no infantry foxholes are dug.

Digging in saves lives and wins battles.

Assad must stay
Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Assad must stay

Right +++, a huge failure. A disaster from top to down, clearly.

Daeshbags Sux
Member
Master
Upvoted
Rookie Mentor
Commenter
Daeshbags Sux

And failure to have the nerve of war : money! Tiger Forces with salaries not paid for 5 months : if even your elite soldiers don’t get paid, things can only get wrong!

kit
Member
Regular
Commenter
Upvoted
kit

Absolutely fascinating. So basically, on the Syrian side were just over 4000 men, the exact same number that ISIS used to attack. And when confronted with an equal sized force… they evaporated. Starting with the Afghans, who were supposed to be among the most fanatical fighters! And the Tiger Forces soldiers who weren’t at their positions due to not receiving pay, first of all who isn’t paying them (Syria, Iran and Russia are all incapable of paying basic wages?!) and secondly what patriot abandons his position and leaves his countrymen to die?! It all affirms my belief that Arabs are… Read more »

Member
Newbie
Commenter
Upvoted
Pierre Bush

There is a reason why many Muslim countries have such weak armies….no loyalty and discipline…there is no reason why the US military should have been able to defeat the Iraqi military in a span of a few weeks in Operation Desert Storm & the Iraq War in 2003…

Member
Newbie
Commenter
Upvoted
Pierre Bush

Not surprising…the usage of foreign militia is a huge liability when attempting to fortify your positions. They have no loyalty and thus left the city open to capture after the assault….it is extremely difficult to defend a position when the defenders don’t defend….

Member
Newbie
Commenter
disqus_2XuTV741A4

Buen relato..muesyra personal con moral de comabet heterogenea,defict de equipamiento,parque,vituallas,medios de combate anti blindado aun los mas livianos, cañones antiguos .88 que no disparan a tiempo,incapacidad de asesoria de ingenieria de combate minima, como hacer zanjas profundas imposibles de pasar por un autobomba blindado,areas debiles sembradas con minas terrestres o explosivos y combustible no pagar los sueldos!!! y se podria seguir no se entiende como asesores rusos e iranies no pueden ver esos detalles o entrenar milicias tribales como verdaderos soldados de la moderna contienda. Decepciona como potencias preparadas no contenplan estas situaciones donde caen los verdaderos soldados.

Member
Regular
Commenter
Upvoted
Manuel Flores Escobar

nadie esperaba un ataque de esa magnitud y las fuerzas q defendian Palmira eran voluntarios o reclutas sin formacion militar como la q tienen Hezbollah,Tiger forces, la guardia republicana o los desert Hawk..

Member
Master
Commenter
Upvoted
Cyriak Papasissis

Very sincere & sanguine view , full of honest assessments. Very useful & welcome critique of all that is wrong in the SAA , the noncommittal irresponsible unprofessional behaviors , that are the true reason behind the tremendous losses in land and men suffered by the SAA over the years of foreign transgressions.

Bleipriester
Member
Regular
Commenter
Upvoted
Bleipriester

The article is nonsense. Maybe ISIS propaganda!
For example, who fought back ISIS to buy time for the evacuation of the city, when they all ran away?
https://www.almasdarnews.com/article/syrian-army-counterattacks-palmyra-outskirts-order-secure-city/

kit
Member
Regular
Commenter
Upvoted
kit

Try reading the article dumbass.